iHeartCats is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.
Navigating the vast world of cat nutrition can be a daunting task, especially with the rise of various dietary trends and feeding methods, including cat food subscriptions. These services promise fresh, tailored, and high-quality meals delivered right to your doorstep, with many claiming to be the best subscription cat food on the market. But as conscientious cat parents, we have to dig deeper.
How do these subscriptions measure up to traditional cat foods in terms of nutrition? Are grain-free diets superior? Why is taurine such a hot topic in feline nutrition? And, of course, with so many subscription services available, which ones truly stand out in reviews?
This article delves into these questions and more, providing insights on the pros and cons of subscription-based cat food and offering a comprehensive review of the leading services in the industry. But first, let’s talk about why fresh cat food may be the best option for your cat.
Why is Fresh Food Good For Cats?
A fresh cat food subscription can be a beneficial option for many cat people and their feline companions for various reasons:
Fresh cat food typically contains high-quality ingredients that can offer better nutritional value than some commercially processed foods. Properly formulated fresh diets can provide the vitamins, minerals, and other essential nutrients that cats need to thrive.
Fewer Fillers and Artificial Additives:
Many commercial cat foods contain fillers, artificial colors, preservatives, and flavor enhancers. Fresh cat food subscriptions usually focus on natural ingredients, often eliminating these unnecessary and sometimes harmful additives.
Many fresh cat food subscription services allow you to tailor the food to your cat’s specific needs, whether it’s allergies, weight management, or age-related requirements. This customization ensures your cat gets the most appropriate diet for their individual needs.
Transparency of Ingredients:
Fresh cat food companies often prioritize transparency. You usually have a clearer understanding of where the ingredients come from, their quality, and how the food is prepared.
Having food delivered regularly means you don’t have to remember to buy cat food on your shopping trips. This can be especially beneficial for busy households.
Many cats prefer the taste of fresh food over traditional dry kibble or canned food. This can be especially helpful for finicky eaters.
Fresh foods often have a higher moisture content than dry kibble, which can help increase a cat’s water intake. Since cats aren’t always diligent about drinking water, this can be especially beneficial for their urinary health.
Some fresh food services rotate ingredients to provide variety in the diet. This not only keeps meals interesting for the cat but can also minimize the risk of developing food sensitivities that can arise from eating the same food every day.
Subscription services can sometimes be more environmentally friendly, with recyclable packaging or efforts to minimize waste.
Overall Health Benefits:
Many pet parents report seeing improvements in their cats’ health after switching to fresh food. This might include shinier coats, increased energy, better digestive health, and even weight management.
Before switching, do your research and choose a reputable fresh cat food subscription service. Ensure the recipes are formulated by qualified nutritionists, especially those specializing in feline nutrition, to ensure your cat’s diet is balanced and complete. Always consult with your veterinarian before making significant changes to your cat’s diet. And when considering which subscription cat food will be best for your furry one, take a look at our buyer’s guide to help you cover all your bases.
Buyer’s Guide: What Factors to Consider When Choosing The Best Cat Food Subscription
Choosing the best cat food subscription requires careful consideration of several factors to ensure the health and happiness of your feline companion:
Ensure that the food is formulated to meet or exceed the nutritional profiles established by the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) or another reputable organization. This ensures that the food provides a complete and balanced diet.
Look for high-quality, natural ingredients. Ideally, the first ingredient should be a named meat source (e.g., chicken, salmon). Avoid generic terms like “meat meal.” Steer clear of unnecessary fillers, artificial preservatives, colors, or flavors.
Can the service adjust the food based on your cat’s age, weight, health concerns, or allergies? Customizable options can be especially beneficial for cats with specific dietary needs.
While it’s essential to provide quality food for your cat, it’s also important to consider what you can afford. Determine your budget and find a service that fits within it without compromising on quality.
Some services pre-portion the meals based on your cat’s caloric needs, helping prevent overfeeding or underfeeding.
Look for environmentally friendly packaging options, especially if sustainability is important to you.
Frequency of Delivery:
Consider how often you want or need deliveries. Can the service accommodate your preferred schedule?
Cats can be finicky eaters. Some subscription services might offer a taste guarantee or a trial period to ensure your cat likes the food.
Does the company provide clear information about where they source their ingredients? Companies that are transparent about their sourcing and production practices often prioritize quality and safety.
Reviews and Recommendations:
Look for reviews from other cat owners. Recommendations from friends, family, or your veterinarian can also provide insight into the quality and reliability of a service.
Some cat owners might be looking for specific health benefits like hairball control, urinary health support, weight management, or dental care. Ensure the food you choose can cater to these needs if necessary.
If your cat has known allergies, be extra careful in reading ingredient lists and opt for limited-ingredient diets or hypoallergenic options.
Check the company’s return or refund policy in case you need to make changes or if your cat doesn’t take to the food.
Ensure that the company can consistently deliver to your location. Some subscription services might have limitations based on geography.
Good customer service is essential, especially if you have questions or concerns about the food or your subscription.
Lastly, always consult with your veterinarian when considering a switch to a new cat food. They can provide guidance tailored to your cat’s specific needs.
The 6 Best Cat Food Subscriptions
#1 – Smalls Fresh Wet Cat Food
Smalls Fresh Wet Cat Food offers a delightful fusion of quality and convenience that both felines and their parents will appreciate. Crafted exclusively for our finicky feline friends, each recipe boasts high-quality, natural ingredients that mirror a cat’s natural dietary preferences. The choice of textures, ground or smooth, resonates well with even the most discerning palates. For cat parents, the subscription service eliminates the frequent store trips, ensuring a consistent supply of nutritious meals. Smalls offers fish, beef, chicken, and turkey recipes to please all the kitties. The brand’s dedication to feline health and wellness is evident in every serving, making it a top choice for those seeking the best for their cats.
- High-quality ingredients
- No artificial preservatives, flavors, or colors
- Easy signup and start
- Positive health effects, such as shinier coats and increased energy
- Pricier than some other commercial cat food options
- Might require a transition period for cats used to dry kibble
#2 – Just Food Fish & Chicken for Cats
Just Food’s JustCats Fish & Chicken formulation provides cats with a savory blend that pays homage to their carnivorous roots. With a commitment to transparency, Just Food ensures that cat parents are well-aware of what they’re feeding their beloved felines. Every bite offers a rich combination of wild-caught Alaskan cod, whole Atlantic sardines, and chicken thighs, catering to cats’ innate love for protein-packed meals. And it’s always made without fillers, preservatives, growth hormones, BHA, BHT or artificial coloring. The freshness of the ingredients is palpable, and the benefits are reflected in a cat’s shiny coat and lively demeanor. Subscribing to Just Food takes the guesswork out of meal planning, and it’s a service that understands the unique dietary needs of cats.
- Fresh, protein-packed meals tailored for felines
- High transparency ensures trustworthiness
- Satisfies the natural carnivorous tendencies of cats
- Premium pricing might deter some cat parents
- Limited variety compared to brands with broader recipe ranges
#3 – Cat Person Cat Food
Cat Person is more than just a cat food brand; it’s a dedication to understanding and catering to the intrinsic needs of felines. Their offerings are a testament to a holistic approach toward feline well-being, from nutrition to taste. The varied range of flavors ensures that cats never tire of mealtime, and each serving is a balanced, wholesome treat. Cat parents who have taken the plunge appreciate the brand’s unwavering commitment to quality. The subscription model simplifies meal planning, ensuring a steady supply of goodness. Just take their Meal Plan quiz, test the recipes in your starter box, and then set your plan. That easy, your cat’s dinner is delivered to your door, ready-to-serve.
- High-quality, balanced meals
- Comes in smaller, resealable two-pound bags
- Tailored exclusively for cats, addressing unique dietary needs
- Substantial flavor variety keeps cats interested
- For cat of all ages, including kittens and senior cats
- Some cats might need time to adjust to the new flavors
- Premium price point
#4 – Raised Right Human Grade Cat Food
Raised Right’s “Human Grade” label sets the bar high, offering a promise of unparalleled quality in feline nutrition. Every ingredient is meticulously selected, ensuring cats get nothing short of the best. The brand’s commitment to excellence is reflected in the noticeable vitality, energy, and coat sheen of cats indulging in their meals. Subscribing to Raised Right means entrusting your cat’s nutrition to a brand that understands the nuances of feline dietary needs.
- Premium quality meals with noticeable benefits
- Trustworthiness due to high-quality ingredient sourcing
- Meals that mirror a natural, ancestral diet for cats
- Higher price point might not fit all budgets
#5 – Milk Pet Foods Meal Plan for Cats
Milk Pet Foods emerges as a refreshing contender in the arena of cat nutrition, emphasizing a harmonious blend of natural ingredients and scientific formulation. Each meal from Milk Pet Foods seems like a culinary experience tailored for felines, promising not just taste but also a bouquet of nutritional benefits. The brand’s Meal Plan is designed keeping in mind the varied and evolving dietary needs of cats, ensuring they get a balanced intake at every life stage. Subscribing to their meal plan brings convenience to cat parents’ doorsteps, with thoughtfully crafted meals that cater to the feline palate. While the brand name might evoke curiosity, its dedication to excellence is apparent in every bite.
- Culinary delights packed with nutritional goodness
- Convenient subscription model ensuring timely meals
- Catering to cats at different life stages
- Eco-friendly packaging
- Limited flavor variety compared to longer-established brands
#6 – Savage Cat Food Rabbit + Lamb Box Membership
For those seeking to mirror the wild, ancestral diet of their domestic felines, Savage Cat Food offers an enticing proposition with its Rabbit + Lamb Box Membership. The brand name itself suggests a raw, primal approach to feline feeding, and the product does not disappoint. With a focus on high-quality proteins like rabbit and lamb, Savage Cat Food promises meals that resonate with the carnivorous essence of cats. Subscribing to their box membership ensures a consistent supply of this protein-packed goodness, satiating the inner predator in domestic cats. While the raw feeding approach is lauded by many, it’s essential to transition cats slowly and monitor for any dietary sensitivities.
- Authentic raw feeding experience for cats
- High protein content mirrors natural feline diets
- Subscription ensures consistency and convenience
- Raw diet might not be suitable for all cats and requires careful transitioning
- Might have a limited appeal compared to more conventional diets
FAQs About Cats and Cat Food
Is wet food or dry food better for my cat?
Wet and dry cat foods each have their advantages. Wet food, being moisture-rich, can be beneficial for cats’ hydration, especially since felines aren’t naturally inclined to drink a lot of water. This can help support kidney and urinary tract health. It’s also often more palatable and can be easier for older cats or those with dental issues to consume. Dry food, on the other hand, is more convenient for many parents as it can be left out for “free feeding” without spoiling and may help with tartar control due to its crunchy nature. The best choice depends on the cat’s individual health needs, preferences, and the owner’s lifestyle. Often, a combination of both wet and dry food can provide a balanced approach.
What ingredients should I look for in quality cat food?
Quality cat food should have a named protein source (like chicken, beef, or salmon) as its primary ingredient. Cats are obligate carnivores, meaning they require a diet high in meat. Avoid foods with vague terms like “meat by-products” or “animal meal.” Be sure, though, that recipes include taurine, an essential amino acid crucial for heart and eye health in cats. Look for foods without excessive fillers like corn, wheat, or soy, which may be used to bulk up the food without adding nutritional value. Also, avoid artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors. A shorter, recognizable ingredient list generally indicates a more natural and higher-quality food.
Why is taurine important in cat food?
Taurine is an essential amino acid for cats, playing a crucial role in various physiological processes, including heart function, vision, and reproduction. Unlike some animals, cats cannot synthesize sufficient amounts of taurine from other amino acids, making it a critical component in their diet. A deficiency in taurine can lead to severe health issues, including dilated cardiomyopathy (a heart condition), retinal degeneration leading to blindness, and reproductive problems. Quality cat foods are formulated to provide adequate levels of taurine to meet feline nutritional requirements.
Are subscription cat foods balanced and complete for cats?
Many subscription cat food services prioritize providing balanced and complete diets, often crafted with the guidance of veterinarians or animal nutritionists. They aim to meet or exceed the nutritional standards set by organizations like the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO). However, as with any food source, research and choose a reputable service. Always check their nutritional information, ingredient sourcing, and consult with your vet to ensure the chosen subscription food meets your cat’s specific needs.
Can kittens or seniors eat subscription cat foods?
Subscription cat foods, like other commercial foods, can be formulated for specific life stages, including kittens and seniors. Kittens have different nutritional needs compared to adult cats, requiring more protein and specific nutrients to support their rapid growth. Senior cats might need diets that support joint health, kidney function, or other age-related concerns. Many subscription services offer foods tailored to these different life stages. However, it’s crucial to choose the appropriate formula and always consult with a veterinarian to ensure it’s the right fit for your feline’s age and health status.
How do I transition my cat from their current food to subscription cat food?
Transitioning your cat to a new food should be done gradually to avoid digestive upset. Start by mixing a small amount of the subscription cat food with their current food. Over 7-10 days, gradually increase the amount of the new food while decreasing the amount of the old food. Monitor your cat for any signs of digestive issues, such as vomiting or diarrhea, or any changes in eating behavior. If any adverse reactions occur, consult with your veterinarian. They might provide guidance on the transition or advise if the new food is suitable for your cat.
Are grain-free diets better for cats?
Cats are obligate carnivores, which means their natural diet consists primarily of meat. While some argue that grain-free diets more closely mimic this natural dietary pattern, it’s not inherently true that all grains are bad for cats. Some cats digest grains without issues and benefit from the nutrients they provide. However, some cats might be sensitive or allergic to grains and benefit from a grain-free diet. Recently, there’s been concern about a potential link between grain-free diets and heart issues in dogs, but the research is ongoing and not conclusively linked to cats. It’s essential to consult with a veterinarian to determine the best dietary choices tailored to your cat’s individual needs.
How can I tell if my cat has a food allergy or intolerance?
Food allergies or intolerances in cats can manifest in various ways. Common symptoms include skin irritations (itching, redness, and scabs), recurrent ear infections, digestive problems (diarrhea or vomiting), and excessive grooming or hair loss. If you suspect your cat has a food allergy, consult your veterinarian. They might recommend an elimination diet to pinpoint the offending ingredient. It involves feeding a minimal or hypoallergenic diet and then gradually reintroducing potential allergens to identify the cause.
What should I do if my cat refuses to eat?
If your cat refuses to eat, it’s a cause for concern, as even a short period of fasting can have significant health implications for cats, including hepatic lipidosis (fatty liver disease). Offer different types of food to entice them, whether it’s a different flavor, texture, or switching between wet and dry. Ensure the food is fresh and at an appealing temperature. If your cat still refuses to eat after 24 hours or appears lethargic or exhibits other symptoms, consult a veterinarian immediately. A sudden change in appetite can be indicative of underlying health issues.
How do I read and understand cat food labels?
Reading cat food labels can be daunting, but a few key things can guide your understanding. First, look at the product name; phrases like “chicken for cats” typically mean the product contains a high percentage of that ingredient. Next, the ingredients are listed by weight, so the first few ingredients are the most predominant. Ensure a quality protein source is at the top. Also, look for the nutritional adequacy statement, which tells you if the food provides complete and balanced nutrition and for which life stage. Lastly, “by-products” aren’t inherently bad and can be nutritious, but “named” by-products like “chicken liver” are preferable over generic terms like “meat by-products.” When in doubt, consult with a veterinarian or feline nutritionist for guidance.
In the ever-evolving landscape of feline nutrition, cat food subscription services offer a promising alternative, prioritizing freshness and customization. As with any choice we make for our beloved pets, due diligence and consultation with veterinary professionals are crucial. Armed with knowledge and a discerning eye, cat parents can navigate these services to find the best dietary fit for their feline companions, ensuring a happy and healthy life.