iHeartCats is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.
We all love to pamper our pets, but when it comes to cats, the finicky feline can often be hard to please. Treats are a great way to bond with your cat, provide a little extra nutrition, or incentivize good behavior, but what do you do when your cat turns up its nose at the usual offerings? In this article, we will explore the best treats that even the pickiest cats can’t resist, taking into account factors such as taste, nutritional content, texture, and ingredients.
#1 – ORIJEN Original Freeze Dried Cat Treats, Grain Free Treats for Cats, Raw Animal Ingredients, 1.25oz
ORIJEN Original Freeze Dried Cat Treats are grain-free treats made with high-quality animal ingredients such as free-run poultry and wild-caught flounder. The treats are freeze-dried to retain their nutrients and flavor. With only 1 calorie each, these treats are suitable for training or rewarding cats.
Best For: High protein, low calorie treats for cats.
#2 – Shameless Pets Crunchy Cat Treats – Catnip Treats for Cats with Digestive Support, Natural Ingredients Kitten Treats with Real Chicken, Healthy Flavored Feline Snacks – Catnip N Chill, 3-Pk
The Shameless Pets Crunchy Cat Treats are catnip treats that provide digestive support for cats. They are made with real chicken, sweet potatoes, and catnip, and packed with pre and probiotics to help with digestion. These low-calorie treats are free from corn and soy and are made with locally sourced ingredients. They are easy on the cat’s stomach and digestive system and are proudly made in the USA using sustainable practices.
Best For: Cats in need of digestive support.
#3 – Vital Essentials Freeze Dried Cat Treats, Raw Chicken Hearts Treats for Cats 0.8 oz
Vital Essentials Freeze Dried Cat Treats are made from responsibly sourced, premium butcher-cut chicken hearts. These freeze-dried treats are packed with protein and contain naturally occurring vitamins and minerals for optimal health benefits. Proudly American-crafted, Vital Essentials products are made without any additives, fillers, or artificial preservatives.
Best For: Cats with allergies or picky eaters.
#4 – Delectables Savory Broths Lickable Wet Cat Treat Variety Pack, 12 Pack
The Delectables Savory Broths Lickable Wet Cat Treat Variety Pack contains twelve 1.4-ounce pouches of a new texture that combines meat and seafood in a savory broth. The treat is grain-free and does not contain any added fillers, artificial colors, preservatives, or by-products. It can be used as a cat food topper, a quick snack, or a special treat that even finicky eaters will enjoy.
Best For: Finicky eaters and those looking for a versatile wet cat treat.
#5 – Rachael Ray Nutrish Love Bites Cat Treats, Chicken, 30 Ounce
Rachael Ray Nutrish Love Bites Cat Treats are crunchy treats for cats that are made with real chicken as the main ingredient. These treats have a crunchy texture that helps clean teeth and do not contain any artificial flavors or poultry by-product meal. Additionally, a portion of the proceeds from the sale of this product goes towards helping animals in need through The Rachael Ray Foundation.
Best For: Helping clean cats’ teeth while providing a tasty treat. (best on a budget)
#6 – Whole Life Pet Freeze Dried Chicken Cat Treats – Human Grade – One Ingredient – Sourced and Made in The USA
The Whole Life Pet Freeze Dried Chicken Cat Treats are made from pure human-grade chicken breast sourced and produced in the USA. These treats have just one ingredient and are minimally processed, avoiding the use of preservatives, fillers, chemicals, salt, or artificial ingredients. They are ideal for all cats, especially those with finicky eating habits, stomach sensitivity, or weight concerns.
Best For: Cats with training needs, finicky eaters, or weight concerns. (best ingredient sourcing)
#7 – Vitakraft PurrSticks Meaty Cat Sticks – Chicken – Segmented and Breakable Meatstick – Deliciously Tender
The Vitakraft PurrSticks Meaty Cat Sticks are deliciously tender treats for cats made with real chicken, turkey, and chicken liver as the main ingredients. These meaty sticks have a high meat content of over 70% and are segmented for easy portioning. They are also free from artificial colors and flavors, making them a healthy option for your cat.
#8 – Jungle Calling Freeze Dried Dog and Cat Treats – High Protein, Low Fat, Made with a Single Ingredient – Perfect for Training and Snacking, 2.8 oz (Duck Cube)
Jungle Calling Freeze Dried Dog and Cat Treats are made with a single ingredient – pure duck – and have a high protein content of over 80%. The freeze-drying process preserves the nutrition and texture of the duck cubes while extending their shelf life. These treats are convenient and portable, making them perfect for training and snacking on the go.
#9 – FELINE GREENIES SMARTBITES Skin & Fur Crunchy and Soft Natural Cat Treats, Salmon Flavor, 2.1 oz. Pack
The FELINE GREENIES SMARTBITES Skin & Fur Crunchy and Soft Natural Cat Treats are a nutritious option for cat owners looking to improve their pet’s skin and fur health. These treats are made with natural ingredients, including fish oil and ground flaxseed, which provide omega-3 fatty acids for healthy skin and fur. With only 2 calories per treat, these crunchy and soft treats are a low-calorie option for rewarding your cat.
Best for: Maintaining healthy skin and fur in cats.
#10 – PureBites Chicken Breast & Catnip Freeze-Dried Cat Treats 1.3Oz / 37G | Value Size
PureBites Chicken Breast & Catnip Freeze-Dried Cat Treats are a popular choice among cat owners. These treats are freeze-dried to preserve their aroma, texture, and freshness, making them irresistible to cats. They are made with 100% pure chicken breast and catnip, making them a healthy and nutritious option for cats with health issues or those on restricted diets. Proudly sourced and made in the USA.
#11 – TEMPTATIONS Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats Shrimpy Shrimp Flavor, 16 oz. Tub
The TEMPTATIONS Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats in Shrimpy Shrimp Flavor is a popular cat treat that combines a crunchy exterior with a soft inside. With under 2 calories per treat, it is a guilt-free option for rewarding cats. The treats are nutritionally complete and can be used as a treat, a meal supplement, or a food topper.
Best For: Cat owners looking for a tasty and affordable treat option. (best on a budget)
Conclusion: Best Treats for Picky Cats
Finding the perfect treat for a picky cat can sometimes feel like a quest for the Holy Grail, but armed with the right information, you can make a selection that satisfies even the most discerning feline palate. Whether your cat prefers freeze-dried, soft, or crunchy treats, we’ve got you covered. Remember, treats should not replace a balanced diet but can be a delightful addition to your cat’s nutrition plan. So go ahead and add that extra dash of love to your pet care routine with a treat that your fussy cat will truly enjoy.